有限责任公司股东的法律救济Judical Remedy for Shareholder Dispute
马俊驹,林晓镍
摘要(Abstract)：
有限责任公司具有封闭性、人合性和所有与经营相一致的特点 ,公司股东面临股份公司股东未有的困境。为保护有限责任公司股东的利益 ,各国在立法上或司法上采取了许多顺应有限责任公司特殊要求的股东救济措施。根据对英、美、德等国的比较法考察 ,为使有限责任公司的股东摆脱困境 ,应赋予股东强制解散公司与收买股份请求权 ,扩大直接诉讼的范围 ,并鼓励股东事先约定解决争议的方法。
关键词(KeyWords)： 有限责任公司;股东;法律救济
基金项目(Foundation):
作者(Author): 马俊驹,林晓镍
DOI: 10.16366/j.cnki.1000-2359.2001.04.012
参考文献(References)：
- [1]王保树 .经济体制转变中的公司法面临的转变 [A].商事法论集 ,第 5卷 [C].
- [2 ]张仲福 .联邦德国企业制度 [M].北京 :中国法制出版社 ,1990 .2 3.
- [3]Robert B. Thompson.The Shareholder's Cause of ActionFor Oppression[J]. Bus L aw.1993.70 9.
- [4]Robert W.Hamilton.The L aw of Corporations[M].WestGroup,1996 .30 1- 30 2 .
- [5 ]Robert C.Clark. Corporate law[M].L ittle,Brown andCompany,1986 .795 .
- [6 ]Robert B.Thompson.The Shareholder's Cause of ActionFor Oppression[J]. Bus L aw.1993.718.
- [7]Harry J. Haynsworth.The Effectiveness of InvoluntaryDissolution as A Remedy for Close CorporationDissension,[J]. 35 CL EV. ST. L. Rev. 1986 . 5 0 ;Hetherington & Dooley.Illiquidity and Exploitation :AProposed Statutory Solution to The Rem aining CloseCorporation Problem[J]6 3Va.L.Rev. 1977. 30 - 34
- [8]Robert B.Thom pson. The Shareholder's Cause of ActionFor Oppression [J].Bus L aw.1993.735 - 736 .
- [9]Robert W.Ham ilton,The L aw of Corporations [M].WestGroup,1996 .2 94- 2 95 .
- [10 ]Sandra,Miller.How Should U.K and U.S MinorityShareholder Rem edies For Unfairly Prejudicial orOppressive Conduct Be Reformed?[J].Am.B.L. J.1998.5 95 .
- [11]U.K.Comm ission.Consultation Paper No.142 .1996 .8.1.
- [12 ]1973 AC 36 0 (Eng. H. L .) 379.
- [13]Hollington,Robin. Minority Shareholders Rights,[M].L ondon:sweet & Maxwell,1994.33- 42 .
- [14]转引自张民安 .现代英美董事法律地位研究 [M].北京 :法律出版社 ,2 0 0 0 .5 71- 5 72
- [15 ]Sandra Miller.Minority Shareholder Oppression in thePrivate Company in The European Comm unity:ACom parative Analysis of The Germany,U nitedKingdom ,and French“Close Corporation Problem”[J].Cornell Int'l L.J. 1997.40 3- 40 4.
- [16 ]U.K.L aw Comm ission.Report No.2 46 ,1997.
- [17]Hugh T. Scogin. Jr. Withdrawl And Expulsion inGermany:A Comparative Perspective on the “CloseCorporate Problem”[J].15 Mich J.Int'c L .1993.12 7.
- [18]Jill Poole and Pauline Roberts. ShareholderRemedies—— Corporate Wrongs and the DerivativeAction[J].J.B.L. 1999.111- 118.
- [19]汤欣 .公司法的性格—强制法抑或任意法 [A].中国法学会民法学经济法学研究会 2 0 0 0年年会论文 [C].